The short version
Star Council is Supreme's top annual award for councils. It's won by hitting three separate performance targets within the same fraternal year, while also staying in Good Standing on compliance paperwork.
Most councils that aim for it get one or two of the three. Getting all three is the hard part — and that's what makes Star Council meaningful rather than routine.
Here's how the math actually works.
The trifecta
Three named awards. Win all three in the same fraternal year and your council earns Star Council.
1. Father McGivney Award — Membership
The target: hit the membership quota Supreme assigns your council each fraternal year (July 1 – June 30). Per the Fraternal Excellence Guide 2025, growth is measured by intake only — brand-new members joining your council. Withdrawals, suspensions, and deaths do not count against your quota, and transfers in or out don't count for or against it either. Reactivating inactive insurance members counts toward both McGivney and Founders'.
How to find your quota: it's listed under the Membership tab in Officers Online, updated daily.
No application needed. Eligibility is automatically determined by the Supreme Council — if you hit your intake quota, the award is yours.
Why this is hard. Your quota is set so that a healthy council has to work to clear it. Most councils that miss Father McGivney miss because they didn't bring in enough new members — retention losses don't hurt you here, but they do make the council feel smaller and make recruiting harder, which is the indirect way attrition bites.
2. Founders' Award — Insurance
The target (per FEG 2025): host or promote at least two Fraternal Benefit Events (FBEs) during the fraternal year. College and Military councils only need one. The combined attendance of members (plus eligible men) across the FBEs must reach a minimum:
- 10 total attendees for councils with 99 or fewer members
- 14 total attendees for councils with 100+ members
Shortcut for small councils: if the GK and DGK each meet one-on-one with the council's Field Agent for a personal fraternal-benefits review, those two meetings count together as one of the two required FBEs. College and Military councils can't use this shortcut.
What counts as an FBE: educational presentations (in-person or virtual) hosted by the General Agent or Insurance Agent covering topics like retirement planning, estate preservation, charitable gifting, and the fraternal benefits of Knights membership. They're open to current and prospective members.
OCONUS military councils are exempt from the two-FBE requirement — they're not penalized on Star Council for this if everything else is in order.
No application needed. Like McGivney, the Founders' Award is determined automatically by Supreme based on the FBEs your general/field agent registers on your council's behalf. Coordinate with your agent early in the fraternal year so the events get logged.
3. Columbian Award — Programs
The target: Earn at least 4 program credits per pillar (Faith, Family, Community, Life) — 16 credit minimum total, no pillar at zero.
The math: Featured Programs that meet minimum requirements earn 2 credits each; all other qualifying programs earn 1 credit. So a mix of 2–3 well-run Featured events plus a handful of standard events clears each pillar. You still need balance: 15 Faith credits and zero Community credits won't earn Columbian. The 4-per-pillar floor forces a well-rounded program calendar.
Why it's the hardest leg. Programs require the most volunteer coordination across the longest time horizon. A weak Program Director or an absent pillar director quietly kills a pillar's credit count months before anyone notices.
See Faith in Action Pillars for what counts in each pillar.
The compliance gates
Winning the trifecta isn't enough. Your council must also be in Good Standing — which means these are filed on time:
- Form #185 — Report of Officers Chosen for the Term (filed after officer elections, due June 30)
- Form #365 — Service Program Personnel Report (July 1)
- Form #1728 — Annual Survey of Fraternal Activity (January 31, covers prior calendar year)
- Form #1295 — Annual Council Audit (August 15, covers prior fraternal year)
- Supreme Per Capita — paid in January
- State Per Capita — paid on state-specific schedule
Miss any of these and your Star Council eligibility can be paused or denied regardless of membership, insurance, and program performance.
See Good Standing checklist for the full list.
Why the three-award structure matters
Star Council forces balance across the three things a Knights of Columbus council is supposed to do:
- Grow. A council that doesn't recruit dies in 20 years.
- Support its insurance mission. The Order's financial foundation depends on insurance participation.
- Serve its parish and community. Programs are why the council exists publicly.
You can't paper over a weak pillar with strength in another. A recruiting-heavy council that runs no programs fails Columbian. A program-heavy council that never talks to its Field Agent fails Founders'. A council that does both but loses 20 members to attrition fails Father McGivney.
Star Council is recognition for councils that are functional across all three. That's why it's a real bar, not a participation trophy.
What councils actually get
- Star Council banner displayed at state convention and prominently in Supreme communications.
- Listing in Supreme publications (the magazine, annual reports).
- State-level recognition at state convention — many state councils also award at state level.
- Eligibility for higher-tier awards (Double Star, Triple Star, state-specific stars).
- Retention lift. Members of a Star Council tend to stay engaged — it's social proof that the council is functional.
- Recruiting lift. Star Council status is a credible "we're good at this" signal to prospective members.
The trophy is the visible thing. The real prize is what a Star Council council tends to be in practice: a council with a working officer line, a real Program Director, active recruiting, and clean books.
Common reasons councils miss
- The Program Director vacancy. A council without a functioning Program Director underperforms on Columbian almost every year. Fix this first.
- Stalled recruiting in spring. Councils that hit 3 net members by January and assume they'll catch up often don't. The spring recruiting push is usually less productive than the fall one.
- Forgotten Founders' events. "We'll schedule the Fraternal Benefit Night next month" → "Oh, it's April, we have to do two events by June 30." Don't let this slip.
- Late #365 filing. Your Columbian clock doesn't start until #365 is on file. See Form #365 for how this mechanic works.
- Audit slippage. A late #1295 puts you out of Good Standing. Trustees need to own the August 15 deadline, not hope the FS reminds them.
How to run the year for Star Council
July – August: File #185, file #365. Lock in pillar directors. Schedule first Founders' event for fall. Set recruiting goal (at least 7–8 net to leave a safety margin on Father McGivney).
September – December: Execute programs across all four pillars. Hit one Founders' event by December. Track Columbian credit count monthly.
January: File #1728. 1st Supreme assessment levied. Mid-year Columbian audit — which pillar is weak?
February: Informal Trustee check-in on books (keeps the August audit clean). Schedule second Founders' event for spring.
March – April: Recruiting push to close Father McGivney gap. Catch-up programs for weakest pillar. Pay 1st Supreme assessment by April 10.
May: Officer elections. Count final Columbian credits. Confirm Founders' event #2 is scheduled.
June: Hold Founders' event #2 if not already done. File SP-7 by June 30. File #185 for incoming officers by June 30.
July – August (new year): Form #1295 annual audit due August 15. Everything rolls over. Begin again.
Use the Star Council Calculator to track your progress live across all three awards.
Source notes. Draws on the Fraternal Excellence Guide 2025 (authoritative source for the current-year Star Council / Father McGivney / Founders' / Columbian Award criteria), Faith in Action program materials, Form SP-7 instructions, and the Grand Knight Handbook (#915). Send feedback if anything's off.
Last reviewed: April 18, 2026. Fraternal year 2025–26.
Built by a Financial Secretary
Stop running this by hand.
DuesSync runs your council's dues collection end to end — online payments, automatic notices, reconciliation, and the audit trail.
Free for Founding Councils through June 2027 — no council vote, no credit card.
Start free